Forging Documents For Profit

11 January 2011

Here is the math I just did (and posted to wowhead) to see where the Forged Documents inscription recipe would “cap” herb prices in World of Warcraft:

40s = rep-discounted resilient parchment price
10g = conservative forged document average (sounds like it goes up to 30g, so it may be more like 20g average)
3 blackfallow ink = 1 stack of 20 high-end herbs, since they net 6 pigment

You should only buy+mill herbs to forge documents if:
(Cost of forging documents) < (Profit from forging documents)
40s + 20*(1 high-end herb price) < 10g + (1 inferno ink)
20*(1 high-end herb price) < 9g60s + (1 inferno ink)
high-end herb price < 48s + (1 inferno ink price) / 20

Low-end herbs get 5 pigment per stack instead of 6, and generate half an inferno ink per stack:
low-end herb price < 48s * 5/6 + (1 inferno ink price) / 40
low-end herb price < 40s  + (1 inferno ink price) / 40

You can use blackfallow ink for other things, so you also want to make sure it’s cheaper to craft than your profit from the forged documents:
3 blackfallow < 1 forged documents = 10g – 40s (parchment)
3 blackfallow < 9g60s
1 blackfallow < 3.2g
AND Backfallow Ink is worth < 3.2g

10 Blackfallow can be traded for 1 Inferno ink, so you also want to make sure:
Inferno Ink < 10 * blackfallow ink value
AND Inferno Ink is worth < 32g

Considering the glyph and Darkmoon card markets, it won’t be worth spending inks on forging documents any time soon.  Even late in Cata with a huge herb supply, lower glyph prices, and lower demand for these mats, I don’t think forging documents will cap herb prices.  Each scribe can only forge 1 set of documents a day (1 stack of herb) — there aren’t enough scribes to forge a significant percentage of the herb gathered daily.

That said, this recipe is one of those knobs the designers could turn to increase herb prices later on — either by increasing the sell value of the forged documents or by lowering the cooldown.

This entry was posted on 11 January 2011 and is filed under Games.

Comments are closed.